The Countess Dubarry (Anne Hathaway) and the Marshal Richelieu (Jack Nicholson) would have gotten the "Sad" prize at the costume party. She's disguised as a "regular" about-Paris chick, her face is hooded; he's on a gray suit, passing (badly) for her servant; and the two stand shaking on the lobby of Joseph Balsamo's house. Even the lobby is mysterious.
Joseph (Johnny Depp) inspects his visitors and sighs: "Good night, Madame Dubarry. Marshal Richelieu."
The old Marshal shakes some more, Dubarry throws back her hood: "I told you these costumes sucked, Richelieu!"
Joseph bows before the old man: "Oh, I would have recognized him no matter what dress he donned. It's only natural, since I've saved his life on a previous ocassion."
The Marshal snorts: "You! Saved my life? We just met!"
Joseph shakes a finger: "Now, it's not nice to forget the man who resurrected you! 1725? Vienna? Ring a bell?"
Since Richelieu was just relating such an event, bells are ringing: "But you weren't even born in 1725! You look like you're in your '30s!"
Madame Dubarry laughs: "I told you he was the real deal, wizard-wise."
Joseph goes on: "At that time, I was not calling myself the Count de Fenix. It was the fashion to have wizardly names end in -us and -as. Perhaps the name of Althotas whisks away all doubt?"
The Marshal nods fearfully. The Countess Dubarry intervenes: "You have been on our minds, 'Count de Fenix'. Recall you once promised I would be Queen of France?"
BALSAMO: "You're as queen in my heart"
DUBARRY: "That's sweet, but it doesn't help me build palaces!"
RICHELIEU: "Let us not pussyfoot around with this wizard. Someone stands in our way. It won't be as easy to bring that individual down as it was to resurrect me."
B: "Oh no, it will be much easier! Mere words could bring down Prime Minister de Choiseul."
D: "You know who we mean, then. But of course you do! You know everything."
B: "It doesn't take magic to figure out. And I see that Richelieu has a particular wish to make."
D: "Ah, Marshal! You didn't say you had wishes!"
R: "Because it's embarrassing! For you! May I ask in private?"
D: "I'm wearing rouge, trust me: ain't NOTHING gonna make me blush. Ask in public."
R: "Mr. de Fenix! It seems to me His aging Majesty is no longer as... amusable... as he used to be. Perhaps there is some philter to make him more amenable to Madame's charms? I was told to ask about Le Viagre. Maybe I can have a free sample? Make that two."
D: "That's not what we came here for, old goat!!" She punches the Marshal in the left kidney.
Joseph smiles: "I'm afraid Madame Dubarry is right. Even if the King loved her a hundred times more, which is mathematically impossible, De Choiseul would be as unmovable in his seat as always. No, let's go with something much easier. All the two of you need, after all, is prove to the King that De Choiseul is a traitor."
R: "A traitor! How so?"
B: "Why, doesn't he support the Parliament against Royal Authority?"
D: "And how does he that?"
B: "Promising immunity to agents of discord. Take Madame de Grammont and her so-called 'exile'. Does anyone doubt she's riling up forces in the country? Does anyone doubt De Choiseul support his sister? Does anyone doubt he plans to start a war with England that would make him indispensable? Isn't Madame de Grammont conspiring to a similar aim? There, that's your treason."
D: "One can't make that kind of accusations without proof, though."
B: "Too true. Get proof, then, my Dear Countess."
Richelieu goes into a display of sarcastic mirth: "OH, yeah, get PROOF! Why didn't I think of that! Maybe I left the PROOF under my couch back home! Let's get out of here, Countess, this was truly a magical evening!"
B: "Calm down now. The proof is easy to find. A simple letter between Madame de Grammont and Monsieur de Choiseul will suffice."
Madame Dubarry falls before Balsamo: "My good, good wizard! Make that letter appear for us! I would do anything, and I mean ANYTHING, wink wink etc etc..!"
Joseph laughs: "No such display will be necessary, since it's all too easy to get it. Why, it's in my pocket right now!" He brings out a folded piece of paper to general astoundment. He reads it- indeed it's a letter from Madame de Grammont compromising Monsieur de Choiseul, as we saw in the previous chapter.

Richelieu froths at the mouth: "That's a fake. It has to be. This wizard is conning us!"
"It IS a fake," Balsamo admits. "Or rather not the original. A copy I made. The real one is right now being delivered to the Prime Minister."
Dubarry reflects on this: "No, if someone has read that letter, they must have opened the seal... and kept it. And perhaps will sell it to the highest bidder."
B: "That's only for people who need to open envelopes to read what's inside. Or people who CARE! What do I win from ruining Monsieur De Choiseul and his sister? You asked me advice as friends, and I gave it, that's all. I'm not a two bit psychic, you don't see me asking you for a quarter for my consultation!"
D: "It's just... It's all so suspicious! How could you know of that letter?"
B: "I have spent thousands of years to gain my supernatural powers- and you want to just KNOW it all in one second? I keep my means to myself."
R: "Bah, thousands of years! Don't get me wrong. I'm grateful for you 'saving me'- even though you looked old, and wrinkly, and like a different guy altogether then. But you're losing credibility here."
B: "What you believe- or not- is your business."
D: "Oh, don't be impatient, my good sorcerer! Richelieu is one of those skeptics."
B: "You can't be impatient when you command time, my dear Countess. You ask signs and methods. Well, why not? Why keep what's pure as light in the dark? I get my visions from..." (Madame Dubarry and Richelieu lean forward so far they could have fallen into the Seine) "... a VOICE."
"He's a nut, a quack" says Richelieu.
B: "I would be, if the voice came from my head. But what if you too could hear it, if it was as audible as the clarion of the angels? Wanna hear it?"
R: "Hell yeah!"
Balsamo stares at his two visitors icily until they're shivering like someone let the North Pole sneak up on them. "Very well," he finally says. "Any of you speak Aramaic?"
R: "Make it a French voice. If it's the Devil, it probably speaks French. I know, because Voltaire speaks French."
Balsamo beckons the curious to a post behind the stairs, promising them safety from otherworldly powers if they only remain hidden. We know, don't we, that behind that wall is the gilded cage that Lorenza Feliciani (Monica Bellucci) refuses to call home. Balsamo whispers, in an Arabic tongue unkown to the guests: "My friend, if you're there, if you sense me, ring a bell twice."
Nothing happens, and a triumphant chuckle begins to form in Richelieu's throat when there's the double ringing of a bell and the old man nearly chokes. Madame Dubarry ducks behind the tail of his coat. Still speaking in Arabic, Joseph gives instructions to "trancey-Lorenza" to press the button that correctly makes the chimney in her room girate, depositing her a tapestried wall away from where Joseph waits.
"What, ah, language was, er, that?" Asks Richelieu, trying to affect a scientific interest through the stuttering of his fake dentures.
B: "A cabalistic language. Worry not, the spirit will address us in French. Perhaps tinged with some tones from other realms, but I can't control that."
The Countess is praying: "Oh Papa God, I know I haven't been the chastest of Christians but don't let the Devil take me, please please please Ave Maria Pater Noster..."
Balsamo: "I said nothing about the Devil. As a matter of fact, I have reason to suspect this voice belongs to a good angel." He puts his palm flat against the tapestry in the wall:
"And the angel is going to speak NOW!"