
Catholic guilt lays heavy, HEAVY, on Daredevil's "Guardian Devil" storyline, which refueled the character in the late '90s. There was the question at the time if Kevin Smith could write comics. He was perceived as a resourceful, transgressive potty-mouthed indie director as opposed to the play-it-safe, commercially-minded hack he's perceived as now (it's even more apparent because he's unsuccesful at that commerciality. Nothing as sad as pop music that isn't popular.)
The consensus now is that he's much more in control of his direction when writing comics than when making movies.
"Guardian Devil" has been criticized for aping Frank Miller's "Born Again" Daredevil storyline (which I haven't read yet) but it's only natural that Smith would base his first major superhero storyline on someone else's succesful structure. What's here works, and is ocassionally very moving. Daredevil is placed in charge of a child who might be the Antichrist, and all of the character's religious preconceptions serve to deliver him up to a (surprising) villain, as his world crumbles around him.

SPOILERS: Mysterio, the smoke-and-mirrors orb-headed Spider villain, has cancer, decides to have one last hoorah. Spiderman not being available, Mysterio creates a needlessly intricate set of hoaxy circumstances meant to drive Daredevil to madness. The contrivances are a little too much: if Mysterio didn't have cancer at first, he would have gotten it from the stress of setting up something this ridiculously elaborate. There's a cute baby who may signal the Apocalypse! Longtime bud Foggy Nelson becomes a murderer! Karen Page has AIDS! (This was actually shocking when it happened despite what my exclamation point suggests. But then we learn it was fake-AIDS. But hey, long-time enemy DD enemy Bullseye kills her anyway!)
Religion is rarely treated in mainstream comics- although morality is about ALL they deal with. (Does anyone know Batman's religion? Spiderman's? A church-on-Sundays Superman would seem very silly, all-American as his upbringing was. There ain't no aliens from Planet Krypton in the Bible.) Smith's Catholicism might seem a little too upfront to non-believers or Christians of other denominations, who might not place as much import on Catholic imagery or sacraments like confession, but he balances the dollops of nun-delivered lectures with humor and skepticism. After all, all the Heavenly signs along the way turn out to be chemically-induced. This is an above average story, and if there's a problem here, it's the same as in Smith's movies- there's not enough visual thinking, too much rests on the writing.
But that's good, engaging writing, and Karen Page's final letter to Mr. Matt Murdoch had me teary-eyed.






































