Dear Imaginary Reader:
You and I know that sometime around the year 2000, three agents from the so-called A.V. Club cannily planted a chip under my dorsal fin that allowed them to track my trend-setting likes and dislikes. It's Karma Chameleon Hour, mofos, and here I rip THEM off by going down their list of
"50 Best Movies of the '00s". That's right, Nathan Rabin, Tasha Robinson, that other fat guy; Payback is NOT a Lady.
50- OLDBOY. If "The Count of Montecristo" had been Asian, these would have been the results.
49- GERRY. Never saw it. Not a big Gus Van Sant fan, mainly it's the "Van" thing that turns me off. Such a pretentious name. What is he, a furriner?
48- CRIMSON GOLD. Never saw it. Ah, Iranian movies. Better than Iraqi movies, worse than Palestinian movies.
47- MOULIN ROUGE! A guilty pleasure. It's a terrible, melodramatic experience even by musical standards, but it's so ridiculously hyper it doesn't give you time to hate it.
46- ADAPTATION. This was all idea, very little movie.
45- AUDITION. I am a grown up. I don't get SCARED by some little Asian girl... OMG what IS SHE DOING TO THAT GUY'S LEGS??? OH GOD PLEASE DADDY MAKE HER STOPPPPPPPP!!! *hugs knees and cradles self in corner of room*
44- 4 MONTHS, 3 WEEKS AND 2 DAYS. Maybe it takes someone from a Communist country to really get this great, excruciating Romanian movie. I really got it.
43- BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN. Once you separate it from its cultural significance, it's just a small, well-acted movie, isn't it? Nothing to get all bent about.
42- L'ENFANT. Ah, petty thugs and their little babies. Realistic but manipulative.
41- DARK KNIGHT. Possibly the darkest superhero movie ever? Certainly the best Batman movie, and not likely to be topped.
40- CITY OF GOD. Next time you think that people in Brazil are just happy in their Third World samba-dancing haze, watch this.
39- THE PRESTIGE. About 80% of this movie is excellent, then it has some plot twists that might have made M. Night Shyamalan groan and head for "The Last Airbender." It's clearly only in this list for the Christopher Nolan love. (Key bullshit line in the A.V. Club's blurb:
"Like Memento and The Dark Knight (and Insomnia and Following, for that matter), The Prestige is partly about the fragmentation of self." Yeah. And "The Breakfast Club" and "The Karate Kid," too, for that matter. Isn't that the kind of crap one utters on the way to formulating an aggrandizing auteur theory? The similar "The Illusionist" is about as good, and sadly unloved.
38- SPRING, SUMMER, FALL, WINTER...AND SPRING. Never saw it. The Buddhist in me might have liked it, but the Buddhist in me is too lazy to go see a movie with that soporific of a title. Next lifetime.
37- A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE. Judging by how much critics liked this movie, I get the feeling I missed out on something. I mean, it was a cool, intelligent action flick in my eyes, but clearly other people were seeing something waaaaaaay more significant, and not one of them has been able to explain what that is.
36- PAN'S LABYRINTH. How come this movie knew how to make its fantasy monsters come to life, while its real-life monsters were so one-dimensional? Where's Hans Landa when you need him?
35- WAKING LIFE. I ADORE this movie. One of the most daring trips in cinema.
34- AMERICAN PSYCHO. What's good here is Christian Bale, and the classic Phil Collins/ Genesis speech. What's bad is that the character of this American Psycho is looking for a movie to accomodate it.
33- PUNCH-DRUNK LOVE. Adam Sandler's "serious" turns are always cause for someone to go all like: "Look, he's a REAL actor, he's not funny this time!" Oh, he was funny the other times? I hadn't noticed. Very good movie, though. See the underrated "Spanglish" as well. And the parts of "Funny People" that worked.
32- A.I. I love sooo many aspects of this film- (and no, they're not all necessarily Kubrick's touches)- but rarely has a movie so likable made me go like: "Please end already. Please. You're ruining things."
31- IN THE MOOD FOR LOVE. Wong Kar-wai's movie is seductive, but I could never relate to its character's rigid avoidal of what even the densest audience member knows they should do.
30- WALL-E. Pixar should take 10 spots in this list.
29- CROUCHING TIGER, HIDDEN DRAGON. A ridiculous story to which stodgy critics clung to because they're not used to admitting that a movie can be awesome solely because it's characters can run bamboo blades into the sky.
28- MORVERN CALLAR. Never saw it. Never heard of it before now.
27- WHAT TIME IS IT THERE? Never saw it. Never heard of it before now either.
26- THE INCREDIBLES. This is not one of my favorite Pixar movies- the stress on the action scenes seems to pander to the conventions it would otherwise mock- but with Pixar, merely ok is still pretty great (see also: CARS.)
25- TOGETHER. I am thrilled this movie made it so high on the list. Let me quote the blurb in the site because it mirrors my thoughts exactly:
Swedish writer-director Lukas Moodysson has become disappointingly didactic over the past few years, but he used to be capable of warm, humanistic films like the shambling comedy 'Together,' in which varying countercultural types convene in a commune in 1975 and spend more time debating the nature of their social experiment than they do actually living their principles. Moodysson divides his attention between the bickering grown-ups and the impact their life of rigid idealism has on their kids, who dream of toy guns and hot sausages. Nobody is too good or too bad in 'Together'; they’re all just muddling through, the same as anyone. At a time when we seem increasingly divided by our beliefs, it’s useful to be reminded that no matter how much people posture in public, in private we all have something in common: we’re all compromised.
24- YIYI. See "Spring Summer whatever whatever."
23- THE MAN WHO WASN'T THERE. Never saw it. But it's a Coen Brothers movie: I sort of know what awaits there.
22- UNITED 93. Never saw it. It seemed like 'too soon' at the time, not it's 'too late.'
21- ZODIAC. See "A History of Violence."
20- THE SQUID AND THE WHALE. An all too real tale of divorce and its collateral damage.
19- THE LORD OF THE RINGS. The Star Wars trilogy of our time.
18- MULHOLLAND DRIVE. Great as (much) of this movie is, let's face it: what we all enjoyed was TALKING about "Mulholland Drive" and hoping one of us could explain it to the rest.
17- THE ROYAL TENENBAUMS. I prefer "The Life Aquatic," believe it or not.
16- ALMOST FAMOUS. I'm thrilled this made it so high: aside from some third act problems, this movie may be the reason why I joined the Rolling Stone staff and ended up partying with that guy from Disturbed. Or was it Stained?(Listen, rock and roll ain't what it used to be.)
15- Y TU MAMA TAMBIEN. This one was very instrumental in my exploration of Latin cinema, along with "Amores Perros". Thank you, Gael Garcia Bernal.
14- TALK TO HER. I would have put "All About my Mother" in this list instead, but Almodovar is at his peak here, showing sympathy for characters other filmmakers would have recoiled from or vilified.
13- GRIZZLY BEAR. A great documentary with a valuable moral: you do not fuck with Mother nature. (See Steve Irwin).
12- BEFORE SUNSET. I've always said that nothing is as exciting as a man and a woman in conversation.
11- TIME OUT. Never saw it, but I enjoyed both "The Class" and "Human Resources," so it's a matter of time. Sneaky, elusive time.
10- CHILDREN OF MEN. A smart premise, but it's the masterful, immersive action scenes that made this one memorable.
9- THE NEW WORLD. This movie captures the awe of encounter- not so much between men of different races, but between men and the nature that dwarfs them. (See also "Apocalypto," a great movie that no one defends because, well, it's Mel Gibson and he's a looney.)
8- CAPTURING THE FRIEDMANS. One of last decade's most thought-provoking documentaries. (See also "Bowling for Columbine," "Crazy Love.")
7- KILL BILL. Tarantino is THE best at matching action with conversation, so that the cool fights you see are always grounded on someone saying something interesting.
6-SPIRITED AWAY. Yay, Miyazaki made the list, and quite high on it.
5- MEMENTO. I don't know that Nolan deserved three spots on this list. "The Prestige" oughta go.
4- NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN. Javier Bardem made this one-
3- THERE WILL BE BLOOD.- and Daniel-Day Lewis made this one.
2- 25t HOUR- Edward Norton, (screaming into the mirror about New York and, really, America.) It's all there on that scene.
1- ETERNAL SUNSHINE OF THE SPOTLESS MIND. When I first saw ESOTSM at the movies, a friend said: "I don't get this." I don't think I still talk to that person, and that's for the best.