A Tale of Musical Discovery.
You're about to enter the musical mind-set of an ignorant teenager in an urban, mostly Latin high school.
It's 1997. South Florida. Miami, specifically. Enjoy.
Before he became the prototype of the self-righteous d-bag, Sting was sooo cool. You can't recall, I realize. But try! Try! The Police was one of the first respectable bands I got into, and I am not ashamed to admit that it was P-Diddy who educated me. Oh wait, I meant to say I AM ashamed, but not ashamed enough to NOT talk about it.
I remember 1997 like it was yesterday. Picture me, wearing some rock T-shirt. Let's make it a Marilyn Manson shirt. I guess I DON'T remember it like it was yesterday, but I do remember it was a rocking dark shirt- the darker the better- and it was what I had on when I walked in on my brother listening to "I'll Be Missing You." I hated whatever my brother listened to, and what my brother always listened to was "rap." I haaaated rap. I would get very vocal about it whenever he played Biggie and 2Pac, which was often, and would put on my headphones and listen to Nirvana and Pearl Jam and Guns 'N Roses on my own maddening loop. Notice this wasn't the same schism in the rock kingdom that was playing out throughout America, between classic and heavy and grunge and industrial and alternative and goth and alt country or what not. No no no. In my ghetto Miami high school, this was a more generalized battle, and it involved the minority (Rock) vs. the all-consuming RAP, (with pop being an uninteresting, banal middle ground only the "normies" could care about.)
If you wanted to signal you were in the ghetto but not OF the ghetto, rock was it, the heavier the better. Metallica! Pantera! Sepultura! Things that ended with A! It wasn't a racist thing: our school was uniformly Hispanic. Jimmi Hendrix was a god to the circle I ended up in, for instance. Blues and soul and jazz music were never even remotely hated on. No. It was an "embrace the ghetto"/ "feel alienated in the ghetto" thing. Alienation was clearly the right choice for my peeps! And we hated rap: the way it was repetitive and didn't have enough guitar solos. Worst, it seemed to be specifically about being black, shooting niggaz down, drug-dealing and fucking women. That's four activities from which this non-thug felt excluded: the first by genetics, the next two by morals, and the fourth by crippling nerdiness.
The point is you had to pick sides then, and I naturally went rock. My brother went rap. It was a house divided by stereo. Pretty much the only thing linking my brother and I was a last name, the same living locale, and Run-DMC's take on Aerosmith's "Walk This Way," stretching between us like the rope in our tug-o-war.
But one spring day in 1997, this ignorant young man with the Marilyn Manson t-shirt wanders into a full-on "I'll Be Missing You" crying party. My brother is like: "BIGGIE IS DEAD! This song is about Biggie being dead! It's sooooo beautiful!" And I was listening, and going like: "Damn, this song IS kind of beautiful! But it can't be! I can't allow that to happen! I can't like a rap song, damn it! Why am I finding this song beautiful?!? No way this is coming from that loser Puff Daddy!" (as we then knew Diddy to be called) "The beauty is coming from somewhere else!"
Yup, I had no idea that the Police or "Every Breath You Take" existed. I was 2 in 1983! Don't mock me!
So this exchange took place in my school's rock freak corner:
Me: "Hey, dude, you know that new Puff Daddy song, 'bout Biggie's death? I kind of like it."
Other Rock Guy: "It's because those fuckers stole from the Police!"
Me: "Really? It's that what happened? You think the police did it? I heard it was Tupac's people!"
Other Rock Guy: "No! I mean song is stolen from THE POLICE! The rock band! With Sting!"
Me: "Sting? You mean the actor from 'Dune'?!?"
Other Rock Guy: "You don't know who The Police are?"
Me: "..."
And so Other Rock Guy turned me on to the Police. And two days later, "Synchronicity"- with "Every Breath You Take"- was playing on my house loudly. And my brother came out, with HIS dark T-shirt that was honoring the Notorious B. I. G.- and I triumphantly watched while he had to admit that maybe, just maybe, the success of Puff Daddy was somewhat over-reliant on other people's actual musical accomplishments. I was so thoroughly converted into The Police than less than two weeks later I actually brought a recording of "Don't Stand So Close to Me" to my English class as an example of "allusions to literature in pop culture."
Yeah. Probably not the best song to play in a classroom.
But hey, I hadn't read Nabokov then! Sting led me to Nabokov! And it all started with P. Diddy.
Many, many years have passed and the Police- and Sting- rank significantly lower in my personal totem pole. I see Sting as an able songwriter but a chilly, boring performer, and I abhor his New-Agey phase so much so that I burst out laughing this one time I heard someone at a party actually say: "It doesn't matter how much of a man you think you are, [Sting's] 'Soul Cages' will bring you to your knees crying." (Which was me being a dick, because that album probably HAD brought that guy to his knees crying- and probably about the loss of his father, which is the album's theme. Which is quite an ok thing to cry about. I feel bad for laughing, Guy at a Party! Sorry!)
But thank you, Other Rock Guy, and thank you, P. Diddy, because here I am listening to "Message in a Box: The Complete Recordings" and loving it, noticing that, at their very best, The Police brought a refinement and literacy to the pop singles chart that I sorely miss.
And to my brother: PWNED! ROCK > RAP!
(My brother fittingly replies: "Fuck Tha Police!")